(local rate, even from a mobile)

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

UK Supreme Court finds unanimously for home care worker from Glasgow in major workplace safety decision

Kennedy (Appellant) v Cordia (Services) LLP (Respondent) (Scotland)

The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom has today (Wednesday 10th February) handed down a unanimous decision in favour of Tracey Kennedy, a home carer who was injured while working in Glasgow in 2010.  Tracey Kennedy was represented by Digby Brown. 

The case centred on whether employees working outside in dangerous wintry conditions should be supplied with footwear to protect them against the risk of injury from slipping on ice.

Today’s Judgement upholds a 2013 Court of Session decision in Miss Kennedy’s favour which was initially overturned at appeal in 2014.  Handing down a 5-0 decision, the Supreme Court found that Lord McEwan was right in his 2013 Court of Session opinion when he stated that the direction of the law was to “level safety upwards”.

This case is a landmark judgement which will not only help protect individuals working for the benefit of others in testing conditions across the country, but which further reinforces the need for employers to proactively assess the risks faced by workers when at work, and to introduce reasonable measures to avoid or otherwise reduce that risk.

How the work accident happened

Tracey Kennedy suffered a serious wrist injury while working for Cordia (Services) LLP as a home carer. She slipped on an icy path into a housing estate in Glasgow during the severe winter of 2010 as she made her way to the home of a terminally ill client to provide essential care services.

Miss Kennedy could not re-arrange the visit, was not provided with any footwear by her employer, nor was she given guidance on what she should wear in wintry conditions to avoid her slipping. The footpath had not been gritted and was described as being like a sheet of glass below a layer of snow. Her employer’s own expert described the risk of an employee slipping in these conditions as a “dead cert”.

Breach of health and safety regulations

The Supreme Court has found the risk to Tracey Kennedy’s safety - slipping while travelling between client houses - was “obvious as a matter of common sense” and was known to her employers, having been previously identified.

The lack of a suitable and sufficient risk assessment and a failure to provide suitable protective footwear to protect her from slipping represented a breach of safety regulations and the common law duty of care owed by Cordia.

Discussing risk assessments, today’s decision states that a “reasonably prudent employer will conduct a risk assessment in connection with its operations so that it can take suitable precautions to avoid injury to its employees,” and that a requirement on carry out proper risk assessments “...forms the context in which the employer has to take precautions in the exercise of reasonable care for the safety of its employees."

Tracey Kennedy’s Solicitor, Iona Brown, Digby Brown Associate, said:

“This is an important judgement which will help protect individuals working for the benefit of others in testing conditions across the country.  As the original decision noted, Miss Kennedy was on an errand of mercy, helping a vulnerable elderly member of the community.  No-one should be exposed to any unnecessary risk of injury through just doing their job.”

Fraser Simpson, Digby Brown Partner, said:

“The Supreme Court has made a welcome and unanimous statement confirming that the direction of the law in recent years is to improve safety and health in the working environment, and accordingly safety should always be levelled upwards.

“Individuals going about their work are entitled to reasonable protection from risks to their safety.  Robust risk assessment is now central to consideration of whether an employer has properly fulfilled their duty of care to their employees.

“Digby Brown are committed to applying the law to protect employees, to hold employers to their responsibilities and improve workplace safety standards. We pursued this case, and took it all the way to the Supreme Court because we recognised its importance, both to Tracey Kennedy and thousands of other people at risk of injury when at work. 

“On a wider level, this Judgement is a welcome and important counter-weight to recent changes in the law and public policy which have only served to weaken the protections available to workers in the UK.  We hope this helps re-focus the debate in this area on improving safety for employees.”

Read the Press Release with full details of this landmark judgement 



based on 1419 reviews
  • Excellent service from digby brown, Gail handled the claim professionally and I was always kept up to...
    Laura - 15 Feb 2019
  • I would highly recommend Digby Brown especially Lynne Kerr who dealt with my case always keeping me informed...
    Helen Johnston - 14 Feb 2019
  • Jennifer @ Digby Brown is so amazing and helped me very step of the way in my case . She kept me fully...
    Ms Lynn McCourtney - 14 Feb 2019
  • Amazing service I had never been in a situation like this before and wasn’t even sure about applying...
    Emma - 13 Feb 2019
  • Claire Thomson from Digby Brown Kirkcaldy done my claim, she done great, would recommend.
    Dwayne rowe - 11 Feb 2019
  • Exceeded my expectations, very good service.
    James - 05 Feb 2019
  • I highly recommend Digby Brown Solicitors to anyone who has been unfortunate to have experienced an accident...
    Marion Taylor - 29 Jan 2019
  • Excellent service from Digby Brown Jennifer who dealt with my case was brilliant form start to finish...
    Roseann Allan - 28 Jan 2019
  • I have no reservations what so ever in recommending Digby Brown Solicitors to anyone. Craig the solicitor...
    Sandra Brown - 28 Jan 2019
  • i would highly recommend Digby Brown to any one who may need a solicitor. From first meeting with Wendy...
    Ann - 24 Jan 2019
  • I am very happy choosing Digby Brown and will recommend 100%. Mr Donald Mackay took my case. As a student,...
    Mariela Bankova - 24 Jan 2019
  • Outstanding, proffesional, courteous, great communication and overall an exemplary service.Aleays updated...
    JOHN - 24 Jan 2019
  • First class service and result Excellent cooperation
    Elspeth - 24 Jan 2019
  • My lawyer was Hollie Dilasser in Edinburgh and she was amazing! In constant contact, so helpful, and...
    Alison Pilkington - 23 Jan 2019
  • Great service 👍
    James - 23 Jan 2019
  • An easy pleasurable experience with good advice. Thank you
    james Jackson - 23 Jan 2019
  • Digby brown handled my claim and got a satisfactory result. Well done would recommend them to all
    Harry Heritage - 23 Jan 2019
  • I approached Digby Brown after being knocked down on a pedestrian crossing and on the recommendation...
    Anonymous - 22 Jan 2019
  • really great service highly recommended specialy Magdalena Wlochal-Suchara
    Ella J - 21 Jan 2019
  • I would recommend Digby brown to anyone they will help you in every way they can 😊
    William - 19 Jan 2019